The Meaning of “Legislation Last” in Pension Reform
A concept has come up in several venues related to municipal pension reform, in Rhode island, and it appears that the players are talking past each other a bit. Here’s Gary Sasse, fiscal adviser to the Providence City Council Subcommittee on Pension Sustainability:
Mr. Sasse said that, “The Treasurer’s suggestion that legislation be a last resort is unrealistic given the financial challenges the City of Providence is facing. The wolf is at the door; turning our backs on it and pretending it is not there, is not a practical alternative.”
Not surprisingly, similar points came up at last night’s Senate Finance Committee hearing on just such legislation, submitted by Governor Chafee. If the source of the “legislation last” citation is the workshop on municipal pension reform, however, the phrase wasn’t introduced by General Treasurer Gina Raimondo, but her legal counsel, Mark Dingley.
More importantly, the point wasn’t that other methods of addressing financial difficulties are preferable in some aesthetic way. Rather, it was that changes to pension benefits that are based in legislation (or ordinances) will not stand up to the inevitable legal challenge if municipalities haven’t taken a number of steps first.
Those steps are, in two words, research and prodding. Regarding the first, the municipality has to be able to show in numbers that (1) there is a problem, and (2) certain resolutions aren’t reasonable. For example, if the pension liability is threatening a town with insolvency, then it is clearly a problem, and if data shows that the local demographics indicate a relatively poor community that is already paying a relatively high rate of property taxes, then raising taxes isn’t a reasonable response.
Regarding the second step, prodding, municipalities have to be able to show the courts that they took every possible step to ask and negotiate for concessions, reduce expenditures, and efficiently order their finances. This is undoubtedly what Providence Mayor Angel Taveras as doing when his administration sent letters to all retirees asking for give-backs. Surely, he didn’t expect an overwhelming (or even satisfactory) response, but he can now document that solution as attempted.
It probably won’t hurt communities to have some legislated recourse available to them, but it does create the risk that they’ll reach for its rewards too quickly and fail to build their legal case.
Pingback: harbaremnmn()
Pingback: 1890 silver dollar()
Pingback: Custom challenge coins()
Pingback: More Information()
Pingback: creatine()
Pingback: Constructeur maison ain()
Pingback: Philips Lighting()
Pingback: cash()
Pingback: more info ()
Pingback: PAR30 LED Light Bulb()
Pingback: how to get taller()
Pingback: Get The Best Prices For Your College Books()
Pingback: Concarneau location maison()
Pingback: marijuana led()
Pingback: cash()
Pingback: seo strategy()
Pingback: click cocktails()
Pingback: cash()
Pingback: WordPress Freelance()
Pingback: ImplementSEO web2.0 linkbuilding()
Pingback: roseville pool service()
Pingback: pool service roseville()
Pingback: roseville pool service()
Pingback: penny auction sites()
Pingback: mailboxes()
Pingback: Polished Concrete()
Pingback: Crowd Funding()
Pingback: network marketing()
Pingback: Online Job Search()
Pingback: Prefabricated()
Pingback: Buy Guaranteed Facebook Fans()
Pingback: Odd football()
Pingback: website design ireland()
Pingback: buy youtube views()
Pingback: win the lottery()
Pingback: Ferris Zero Turn Lawn Mowers()
Pingback: rachat credit()
Pingback: pret a taux zero()
Pingback: atvs for sale()
Pingback: atvs for sale()
Pingback: Affiliate Marketing Strategies()
Pingback: personal injury lawyer()
Pingback: Dating Website()
Pingback: publicidad()
Pingback: broker()
Pingback: broker()
Pingback: Smart Battery Charger()
Pingback: asian girls()
Pingback: edheads simple machines()
Pingback: Free ebook()
Pingback: juegos para nokia c3()
Pingback: juegos para nokia c3()
Pingback: Weed Killer For Lawns()
Pingback: find more info here()
Pingback: girls clothing()
Pingback: solglasögon 2012()
Pingback: Sex webcam()
Pingback: ascus aspection billjim()
Pingback: Riverside bail bonds()
Pingback: who unlocks iphones()
Pingback: Emergency Plumber Louisville KY()
Pingback: here()
Pingback: ibuprofen site()
Pingback: Toronto Real Estate Agent()
Pingback: document shredding()
Pingback: california state teachers retirement()
Pingback: payday loans cash advance()
Pingback: best home business to start in 2012()
Pingback: new hampshire dental insurance()
Pingback: Bangalore hotels()
Pingback: royal cruises discount 2012()
Pingback: Get Off Your But()
Pingback: best animation softwares()
Pingback: Sniper Fx Signals()
Pingback: online tv()
Pingback: blog veterinario()
Pingback: Microsoft Webcam()
Pingback: payday loans()
Pingback: buy a house()
Pingback: Asus Vw246h()
Pingback: sleep mask()
Pingback: ledgrowlightsnow.webs.com()
Pingback: Aloe Vera Juice Benefits()
Pingback: auto repair rochester new york()
Pingback: Fertilizer()
Pingback: Electronic Dance Music()
Pingback: Electronic Dance Music()
Pingback: personal trainer singapore()
Pingback: guitar tuner()
Pingback: osteopath()
Pingback: wall panelling()
Pingback: wall cladding()
Pingback: Travel Checklist()
Pingback: jailbreak sites()
Pingback: free download jailbreak iphone()
Pingback: mobile games()
Pingback: nashville seo()
Pingback: social gaming()
Pingback: free games()
Pingback: j joshua beistle()
Pingback: How to increase height after 25()
Pingback: how to obtain british passport()
Pingback: Awesome post! Hey, make sure you check out how I lost over 70 pounds:()
Pingback: chi()
Pingback: Brian Freedman()
Pingback: homes in Utah()
Pingback: calorie finder()
Pingback: jailbreak iphone 4 ios()
Pingback: jailbreak bell iphone 4()
Pingback: bad credit mobile phones()
Pingback: Airplane Games Review()
Pingback: Underarm whitening()
Pingback: Asheville Wedding Photographer()
Pingback: selling a business()
Pingback: earthquake supplies list()
Pingback: Wedding Rings()
Pingback: wen hair care reviews()
Pingback: bowmel chrysler review()
Pingback: watch glee online for free()
Pingback: car loan for bad credit()
Pingback: promotional video()
Pingback: Mauritius Villas()
Pingback: car loan for bad credit()
Pingback: Kyle leon()
Pingback: collision repair mooresville()
Pingback: Calgary photographer()
Pingback: cheap carpet hackney()
Pingback: Financial Freedom()
Pingback: micro niche finder()
Pingback: Immobilier Quimper()
Pingback: Self Catering Accommodation Mauritius()
Pingback: website targeting()
Pingback: amazon shipping promotional code()
Pingback: Makyaj Oyunlary()
Pingback: seo services()
Pingback: Legal Shield Training()
Pingback: MLM Downline Builder()
Pingback: buying cars after bankruptcy()
Pingback: premature ejaculation excersises()
Pingback: cheap jordans()
Pingback: forex()
Pingback: Xango Training()
Pingback: Nikken Training()
Pingback: sex toys()
Pingback: Mannatech Training()
Pingback: Scentsy Training()
Pingback: precious metals()
Pingback: North Koreans()
Pingback: buy Menozac()
Pingback: Persuasive Speech Topics()
Pingback: Edmundo Rech()
Pingback: Thuy Bagdasarian()
Pingback: bol chantant tibetain()
Pingback: Wedding Photographer Sheffield()
Pingback: pilot lawyer()
Pingback: site()
Pingback: U.S. Statewise 2012 CUSTOMER and CONSUMER DATABASES @ fiverr()
Pingback: hen party ireland()
Pingback: plant based protein powder()
Pingback: plant based protein powder()
Pingback: plant based protein powder()
Pingback: service assurance()
Pingback: forex()
Pingback: raw food weight loss()
Pingback: Police auctions()
Pingback: discounted designer handbags()
Pingback: forex()
Pingback: pedometers in bulk()
Pingback: Integrative Nutrition()
Pingback: spondylitis()
Pingback: Location Villa Maurice()
Pingback: tree removal phoenix()
Pingback: austin deck()
Pingback: austin house painting()
Pingback: home water damage services san diego restoration()
Pingback: dyson dc41()
Pingback: driving instructors bexleyheath()
Pingback: drink RE()
Pingback: California Republic Snapback()
Pingback: handbags for less()
Pingback: equity release schemes()
Pingback: Rss feed submission service()
Pingback: reverse phone lookup()
Pingback: More()
Pingback: Buy Facebook fans()
Pingback: Exhibitions and trade fairs()
Pingback: Fridays menu()
Pingback: obituaries template()
Pingback: how to write a obituary()
Pingback: golf netting()
Pingback: Full Report()
Pingback: Spa Montreal()
Pingback: Search Engine Optimization()
Pingback: equity release()
Pingback: ViralURL Affiliate Marketing()
Pingback: unlock iphone 3g with cydia()
Pingback: online dating profile guide()
Pingback: free reverse phone()
Pingback: college degrees online()
Pingback: Buy Turinabol()
Pingback: http://www.casquebluetooth.org/()
Pingback: http://www.barbecueelectrique.org/()
Pingback: http://www.montreautomatique.fr/montre-automatique-homme/()
Pingback: Holiday Villa Rental Mauritius()
Pingback: 6 Volt Battery Chargers()
Pingback: hair removal()
Pingback: sell annuity florida()
Pingback: 2nd hand hifi()
Pingback: personal insurance coverage()
Pingback: kenwood kmix kmx54()
Pingback: sixth street austin()
Pingback: uncut music videos()
Pingback: Dori Stein()
Pingback: professional oven cleaning()
Pingback: http://www.planchaelectrique.net/()
Pingback: interlocking()
Pingback: lil wayne tattoo()
Pingback: tinnitus treatment()
Pingback: http://www.cardiofrequencemetre.org/()
Pingback: rental website()
Pingback: cheap PLR()
Pingback: Roxy()