How Was It Not Obvious That You Never Tell the Enemy When You’ll Be Done?

justin-katz-avatar-smiling

Jessica Donati’s thoughts upon leaving her Afghanistan assignment with the Wall Street Journal are worth a read, if you can get past the pay wall, but this is the part that seems most timely, just now:

The Obama administration’s military surge ended in 2012, but local forces weren’t prepared to take over. The Taliban swept through rural areas, and an Islamic State insurgency took root, capitalizing on popular frustration with a government often seen as dominated by brutal former warlords.

To Our Readers: We need your support to challenge the progressive mainstream media narrative. Your donation helps us deliver the truth to Rhode Islanders. Please give now.

The surge-and-slip-away strategy was an obviously problematic one to anybody who pays even passing attention to human nature and has a cursory familiarity with history.  The same can be said of this, from Vance Serchuk’s commentary on President Trump’s stated policy for that nation (also WSJ… sorry):

The first and most important of [the lesson that Trump appears to have learned from the Bush and Obama administrations’ results] is the rejection of fixed timetables for U.S. withdrawal. Instead the president is taking a conditions-based approach that removes any deadline for pulling out.

That’s significant because America’s recurring efforts to extricate itself from Afghanistan—from the Bush administration’s push to hand over the Afghan mission to NATO, to the Obama administration’s pledge to bring all forces home by the end of its term in office—have helped foster the very conditions that have forced the U.S. to stay.

This U.S. exit-seeking has encouraged the Taliban to think it can outlast America on the battlefield, deterred Afghan civilians from siding with the coalition, and given regional powers like Pakistan incentives to hedge against the U.S. by supporting insurgent groups.

Again, how was this not obvious beforehand?  Scheduling a departure — even making it clear that you’d rather leave than settle in — changes the enemy’s strategy to digging in and waiting.  So, the enemy waited.  Obama looked for the first plausible moment to hand off control to an inchoate authority.  And now we’re still there and moving back in.

Click to help us keep the doors open.



  • Rhett Hardwick

    “Surge” this, “Surge” that. In order to be effective it will be necessary to “occupy” Afghanistan. Not a likely occurrence,. simply turning it over to a supposed government will never work.
    Sherlock Holmes first words to Dr. Watson, after observing his limp from a bullet wound, were “You have been in Afghanistan I perceive”.

  • Merle The Monster

    The arrogance of the Neo-Cons in the Bush Administration and their desire to reshape that part of the world is the single reason the US is still at war. The post 911 disdain for a police action against Al Queda resulted in a poorly managed war against the Taliban and Al Queda in Afghanistan. So now we cant leave until we achieve a result we like in a war that should not have been fought in the first place. Stupidity and folly guide policy. The efforts to extricate ourselves have been criticized by a well meaning military and politicized by the same crowd that got us into this current place.

Quantcast