The Undeserved Confidence of the New Upper Class


One common suggestion for those who wish to be aware of current events and engage in civil dialogue is that they should seek out alternate opinions and actually listen to the other side.  This practice does create a deeper understanding, but deeper understanding doesn’t necessarily bring a softening of reactions.  That was my thought while listening to former long-time PR guy for Democrat Governor Gina Raimondo, Michael Raia, on the Bartholomewtown Podcast.

Please consider a voluntary, tax-deductible subscription to keep the Current growing and free.

Listening to Raia talk about opportunities for our state and region, I couldn’t help but feel my impressions of the Raimondo administration affirmed and my concern about its type of thinking amplified.  The listener can hear how confident Raia is that he’s got the region all figured out, as if a society is just a puzzle for which placement of the correct pieces provides the solution.

Whether it’s the operation of businesses and the economy, the development and modification of the infrastructure, the operations of the healthcare system, or the quality of life of particular demographic groups, like senior citizens, one gets the impression that Raia has a firm belief that he and other go-getter experts can think it all through, plan it all out, wind it all up, and set the great society in motion.  Unfortunately, the human community doesn’t work like that.

Intelligent as they may be, the Raias and Raimondos aren’t smart enough to plan a society even if everybody wanted to live in neighborhoods like the ones they prefer and spend their senior years playing pickleball. Such an accomplishment would require infinite expertise and a God-like perspective.

The fact of the matter, though, is that most other people do not share the tastes of what Charles Murray called “the new upper class” in his book Coming Apart, and those people have a right not to have their societal preferences bulldozed aside by a powerful government.  Moreover, as Murray explains, the ethos of that new upper class is destructive of society in the long run.

Even in the immediate, direct trends of the economy, we can observe the economic sluggishness since Governor Raimondo took office, which suggests that her approach does not work.  In February, Rhode Island was the only state in the country that had fewer jobs than it did a year before.  Yet, one hears no trace of doubt in Raia’s voice that maybe (just maybe) crafting a society isn’t so easy.


Featured image from The Road to Serfdom in cartoons.

  • D. S. Crockett

    Look forward to comments from our esteemed new Republican chair who appears missing in action.

  • Christopher C. Reed

    The ruling conceit of the ruling class is that they’ve got it all figured out, with equations to prove it. We’ve seen this all before.

    Robert Strange McNamara had it all figured out back in the day. He and his Harvard boys, whiz kids all, could prove (with slide rules) how the math was against the North Vietnamese. All we had to do was rack up the body count and the NVA would fold like wet cardboard. Of course they failed to reckon with the Viets’ willingness to die for their country vs. our stomach for killing them. Which shouldn’t have been all that hard to figure out, given that the Viets had been at war with foreign invaders since the 19th Century (and before). The French, the Japanese, the French (again), then the Yanks (basically another kind of Frenchman), with some side trips to rumble with the Laotians, Thais and Khmers. Then, as a kind of bonus proof of their pugnacity they fought off their erstwhile allies the Chinese. So much for Commie solidarity.

    The best laid plans of the whiz kids always come a’cropper on the hard reality of homo sapiens obdurensis. La Raimondo is a Harvard whiz kid, isn’t she?

    • Rhett Hardwick

      You overlooked that the “body counts” in Nam were a sham, altered to reflect desire.

      • Christopher C. Reed

        Huh? Of course the counts were cooked. They were right up there with the other myths, like the “Tonkin Gulf Incident” and “We Never Lost”.

        • Rhett Hardwick

          McNamara should have stayed at Ford, and oh yeah, that haircut. Several years ago I saw a documentary on him where he admits many of his faults and errors.
          “Intelligent as they may be,” not one to denigrate intelligence; the attendant powers of analysis are without value if one does not get out there and observe. It often seems to me that the “whiz kids” (if you will) spend too much time together developing an artificial consensus, without the input of, sometimes tedious, observation. We’re all very smart, we all agree, it must be true.