Mobility Has Held, but Perception and Perspective Have Changed
In an essay analyzing a very specific statistical claim that President Obama made in a speech on December 6, Scott Winship finds that economic mobility has not declined; if anything it’s notched up a tad:
… an ongoing Labor Department survey has followed men and women born in the early 1980s, starting in 1997 when they were adolescents. In 2008, the most recent year for which their incomes are available, they were in their mid to late 20s. A predecessor of this survey (also ongoing) has followed a group born in the late 1950s and early 1960s. Using these two National Longitudinal Survey data sets, I can compare children born between 1962 and 1964 to children born between 1980 and 1982, observing their parents’ incomes when they were 14 to 16 and their own incomes twelve years later when they were 26 to 28.
In contrast to the president’s claim of declining mobility, I found that upward mobility from poverty to the middle class rose from 51 percent to 57 percent between the early-’60s cohorts and the early-’80s ones. Rather than assert that mobility has increased, I want to simply say — at this stage of my research (which is ongoing) — that it has not declined. If I include households that reported negative or no income, the rise in upward mobility I find is only from 51 percent to 53 percent, which is not a statistically meaningful increase. But the data provide absolutely no evidence that economic mobility declined, whereas the president said it had fallen by ten percentage points.
If the president’s statement is incorrect with respect to statistics, it may be dead on with respect to sentiment. According to the Pew Economic Mobility Project’s 2011 poll, more than half of Americans believe that their “children will have a harder time moving up the income ladder” than they did. The percentage who would say that “the American Dream is ‘very much’ alive” has fallen by half, from 34% to 17% since 2003.
Winship goes on to suggest (in the print version of his National Review essay) that this disparity may, in a sense, be self-reinforcing:
… A 2005 Journal of Politics article by political scientist B. Dan Wood and his colleagues found that optimism and pessimism expressed in presidents’ speeches between 1978 and 2002 had a detectable effect on consumers’ sentiments regarding the economy and unemployment, which in turn affected economic growth. So the president’s strategy is likely to hinder recovery from the Great Recession. …
Worse than any impact on middle-class anxiety or even on the strength of the recovery, however, is the message the president is sending to those struggling to pull themselves out of poverty. The data indicate that it is no less true today than it was in the past that poor children can make a better life for themselves. To be sure, it is no more true than in the past, either, a fact that should discourage complacency. But by arguing — against the evidence — that opportunity is on the decline, the president needlessly dampens the hope of those who wish to transcend their disadvantages.
One way to interpret the disconnect between perception and reality is that, metaphorical lottery tickets aside, climbing the ladder of success is hard work. The relevant population, especially its younger members, might therefore be especially vulnerable to messaging campaigns telling people that it is impossible and that government programs must fill in the rungs.
That may explain the responses that Valencia College Economics Professor Jack Chambless received, even before the Occupy movement arose, when he asked about 180 students to describe “the American Dream” and what they wanted the federal government to do to help. (Video of related interview video here.) About 80% said “they wanted free healthcare,” government-financed tuition, government home-loan down payments, and government-granted employment. To some degree, the presentation of the questions could have affected the responses, first presenting the idea of the American Dream and then immediately asking the students, essentially, to imagine that the federal government could have a role in their achieving it. The response, in that context, was not so much socialist as it was unimaginative.
Still, one need only flip through the myriad self-help reality shows (such as The Biggest Loser or My Extreme Animal Phobia) to observe that professionals aiming to help their clients to achieve difficult goals never tell them that the situation is hopeless. They never emphasize how easy the project could be with the right tools or services. Given the state of public discourse about economics, it would be more surprising if young adults were increasingly of the bootstrap school, rather than the government-assistance school.
Economic mobility can be difficult, and it is not a sure thing. But one-in-two odds are hardly insurmountable, and they no doubt improve considerably among those willing to do the work.
Pingback: Sex online()
Pingback: Read more()
Pingback: oval dining table()
Pingback: profumi()
Pingback: marketing on the internet()
Pingback: harbaremnmn()
Pingback: Shakeology Review()
Pingback: website()
Pingback: cash()
Pingback: check this ()
Pingback: SEO Altoona()
Pingback: Have Fun On Your Vacation()
Pingback: cash()
Pingback: Coupons Great Clips Printable()
Pingback: cash()
Pingback: bed bug treatment()
Pingback: chating mit cam ohne registrieren()
Pingback: seo for dummies()
Pingback: Heart health()
Pingback: WordPress Freelance()
Pingback: ImplementSEO web2.0 linkbuilding()
Pingback: pool service roseville()
Pingback: mailboxes()
Pingback: fin 419()
Pingback: str 581()
Pingback: success tips()
Pingback: psy201()
Pingback: Polished Concrete()
Pingback: Concrete polishing()
Pingback: Polished Concrete Floors()
Pingback: Crowd Funding()
Pingback: breast actives pictures()
Pingback: concrete stairs()
Pingback: sex free porn()
Pingback: Mein Neuer Luxuskörper()
Pingback: Juvederm Treatments Denver()
Pingback: credit rapide()
Pingback: Mysticism()
Pingback: buy youtube views()
Pingback: Denver Basement Finishing()
Pingback: Google Glass Project()
Pingback: electrical engineer salary()
Pingback: Nottingham Chauffeur()
Pingback: search engine optimization certification()
Pingback: Best Battery Chargers()
Pingback: Satellite Direct()
Pingback: Smart Battery Chargers()
Pingback: remove google redirect virus()
Pingback: win the lottery()
Pingback: build led grow lights()
Pingback: hypertension()
Pingback: rachat de credit()
Pingback: credit auto pas cher()
Pingback: credit auto()
Pingback: handbags for cheap()
Pingback: adult toys()
Pingback: ipswich escorts()
Pingback: atvs for sale()
Pingback: papildai()
Pingback: presupuestos()
Pingback: dating asian women()
Pingback: edheads knee surgery()
Pingback: incomeathome.com review()
Pingback: homes in utah()
Pingback: Free Download Software()
Pingback: children's clothing()
Pingback: carpet cleaner boston()
Pingback: sale HKS Hi-Power Universal Exhaust Muffler()
Pingback: cherche cougars()
Pingback: aircraftman bodgery allocryptic()
Pingback: Labor laws()
Pingback: iphone unlocks()
Pingback: unlock iphone 3()
Pingback: unlock my iphone o2()
Pingback: document shredding()
Pingback: Assessment Center()
Pingback: Hudson Anywhere Indoor-Outdoor Fireplace()
Pingback: link cloaking()
Pingback: Bowel Obstruction()
Pingback: best home business to start in 2012()
Pingback: OptionFair()
Pingback: limited tort PA()
Pingback: Sex show()
Pingback: Advertising Campaign()
Pingback: NH dental insurance()
Pingback: online insurance ce credits()
Pingback: and they()
Pingback: How to Trade Binary Options()
Pingback: 10x12 shed plans()
Pingback: Why Mobile Website()
Pingback: Window Man()
Pingback: easy stomach exercises()
Pingback: sell gold()
Pingback: watch free movies online()
Pingback: chiropractors rochester mn()
Pingback: Gum disease Long Island()
Pingback: 50 shades of grey()
Pingback: Lacoste()
Pingback: payday loans()
Pingback: neuter clinic()
Pingback: Edinburgh Estate Agents()
Pingback: Internet marketing online()
Pingback: driving range netting()
Pingback: Mallorca Properties()
Pingback: Fast weight loss()
Pingback: Ucla Basketball()
Pingback: ledgrowlightsnow.webs.com()
Pingback: auto repair rochester new york()
Pingback: Girl Dresses()
Pingback: orlando real estate()
Pingback: website builder software()
Pingback: online guitar tuner()
Pingback: Flea treatment for dogs()
Pingback: jailbreak iphone without sim card()
Pingback: Little Palm Island()
Pingback: unlock iphone free()
Pingback: Location Ile Maurice Pas Cher()
Pingback: social gaming()
Pingback: wall paneling()
Pingback: wall panels()
Pingback: wall paneling()
Pingback: j joshua beistle()
Pingback: this()
Pingback: How to grow taller()
Pingback: Young And Reckless()
Pingback: Awesome post! Hey, make sure you check out how I lost over 70 pounds:()
Pingback: military solar()
Pingback: holistic doctors cleveland()
Pingback: pittsburgh pc repair()
Pingback: katzenallergie()
Pingback: carpet cleaner boston()
Pingback: bad credit mobile phones()
Pingback: Location Villa Ile Maurice()
Pingback: make your own website()
Pingback: Asheville Wedding Photographers()
Pingback: unlock orange iphone 4()
Pingback: feminized marijuana seeds()
Pingback: start an online business ideas()
Pingback: wedding Bands()
Pingback: Utah Landscaping()
Pingback: Disney Pin Trading()
Pingback: ERP systems()
Pingback: legal protection insurance()
Pingback: www.ieec.edu.sg/emba()
Pingback: car loan for bad credit()
Pingback: debt forgiveness()
Pingback: Free Rape Porn()
Pingback: marketing tools()
Pingback: Portable Mobile Printer()
Pingback: Studios in Parga()
Pingback: energy healing()
Pingback: Kyle leon()
Pingback: how to make money fast()
Pingback: Melilea Indonesia()
Pingback: king commissions()
Pingback: auto detailing the woodlands()
Pingback: check out this link()
Pingback: KYOLIC GARLIC()
Pingback: How to get rid of your muffin top()
Pingback: Sailing Vacation Florida()
Pingback: Empower Network()
Pingback: multi level marketing()
Pingback: lipo 6 black 120()
Pingback: fap turbo()
Pingback: Naples Jobs()
Pingback: Trading Pursuits()
Pingback: best instrumental music()
Pingback: Kitchen top Singapore()
Pingback: Mauritius Villa Rental()
Pingback: quickquid()
Pingback: implantes dentarios()
Pingback: Emergency Dental Phoenix AZ()
Pingback: Emergency Dental Care Phoenix AZ()
Pingback: Get Rid of Cold Sore Fast()
Pingback: Acupuncture and Chinese Medicine()
Pingback: indien()
Pingback: Downline Builder()
Pingback: Legal Shield Training()
Pingback: car loans after bankruptcy()
Pingback: premature ejaculation excersises()
Pingback: vault denim()
Pingback: currency trading strategies()
Pingback: How To Recruit In MLM()
Pingback: techblog()
Pingback: sex toys()
Pingback: Wireless Electricity()
Pingback: htt250()
Pingback: canadian silver grizzly coin()
Pingback: sex toys()
Pingback: North Koreans()
Pingback: doorbell hardware plate()
Pingback: eXtremeNO review()
Pingback: Extemporaneous Speech()
Pingback: how to unlock an iphone 3()
Pingback: pilot lawyer()
Pingback: Extemporaneous Speech()
Pingback: cheap handbag online()
Pingback: hen party ireland()
Pingback: wholesale designer handbags()
Pingback: forex()
Pingback: Fire Damage Repair Sacramento()
Pingback: best pedometers()
Pingback: ankylosing spondylitis treatment()
Pingback: backlinks()
Pingback: child custody singapore()
Pingback: jewelry distributor()
Pingback: charleston DUI lawyer()
Pingback: effective press release tips()
Pingback: Komputer Repair Birminham()
Pingback: Jacksonville Search Engine Optimization()
Pingback: ipad video lessons()
Pingback: the simple golf swing()
Pingback: puppies()
Pingback: hypnotica()
Pingback: equity release calculator()
Pingback: How to make money on the internet()
Pingback: driving instructors belvedere()
Pingback: RSS Feeds()
Pingback: free reverse phone()
Pingback: Fluxus()
Pingback: Lainavertailu()
Pingback: socialsupercharge.net()
Pingback: Exhibitions and trade fairs()
Pingback: obituaries format()
Pingback: how to write a obituary()
Pingback: wedding hair and makeup()
Pingback: Healthy Living()
Pingback: best mp3 player()
Pingback: networking for businesses Australia()
Pingback: Kilim rug()
Pingback: see more here()
Pingback: equity release()
Pingback: 3HrSalesPower()
Pingback: springfield ma plumbers()
Pingback: unlock iphone 3g 8gb()
Pingback: how to go to sleep()
Pingback: secure shredding services()
Pingback: plumbing()
Pingback: casque bluetooth()
Pingback: http://www.montreautomatique.fr/montre-automatique-homme/()
Pingback: http://www.barbecueelectrique.org/()
Pingback: unlock iphone 3g 3.1.2()
Pingback: how to unlock iphone 3gs for verizon()
Pingback: 6 Volt Battery Chargers()
Pingback: Auto Dealer SEO()
Pingback: Limos in Orlando()
Pingback: Women hair removal cream()
Pingback: check it out()
Pingback: silicone electrical tape()
Pingback: internet marketing tips()
Pingback: custom kitchens melbourne()
Pingback: Visit website()
Pingback: furnished apartments Colombo()
Pingback: Rear Facing Car Seats()
Pingback: acting coach()
Pingback: raw foods diet weight loss()
Pingback: Vehicle tracking()
Pingback: sony playstation()
Pingback: mobile phone deals()
Pingback: personal insurance coverage()
Pingback: Voucher Codes()
Pingback: fat loss()
Pingback: top sports betting site()
Pingback: read more()
Pingback: Dori Stein()
Pingback: Frauengeschenke()
Pingback: ici()
Pingback: best credit cards for people with bad credit()
Pingback: http://www.montregps.org/montre-gps-garmin/()
Pingback: hardscaping()
Pingback: commercial property lincoln()
Pingback: dating review()
Pingback: electrical engineering()
Pingback: cheap PLR()