The Accountability Spin
Here’s the headline from a Rhode Island Department of Education press release about science NECAP scores, out today: “Science assessments show statewide improvement over six-year span.” The average reader can be forgiven for taking that to be great news, and the average cynic can be forgiven for wondering what happened through those six years to make the department reach back so long for its headline.
You can decide for yourself what group Governor Lincoln Chafee falls into. Here’s his statement in the release:
“Proficiency in science plays an important role as we prepare Rhode Island students to succeed in the workforce of tomorrow,” said Governor Lincoln D. Chafee. “I am pleased to see this improvement over time in the results of our science assessments. With continued excellent instruction, our students will make progress in future years as well.”
My vote is that Chafee should receive the cynics’ crown, because he’s surely aware of the year-to-year data. As a matter of fact, overall science NECAP scores have fallen for two years in a row, in Rhode Island.
- 11th graders are stuck at 30% proficient, after hitting a high of 32% in 2012. (As if that’s an acceptable percentage…)
- 8th graders have fallen from last year’s high of 30% down to 23%, losing all gains made since 2010.
- 4th graders managed to hit 46% in 2012, but now they’re stuck at 41%. That’s a mere 1% improvement from 2009.
Overall, 25 Rhode Island school districts saw declines from last year’s scores. Middle schools were particularly bad, with even Barrington’s score dropping 16.7 percentage points. Narragansett middle school led the list of regular districts, with a 30.1 point drop, although The Compass School’s middle schoolers dropped 49.1 points. Some high schools saw gains, particularly North Smithfield, at 19.9 points, but they were exactly canceled out by losses, such as Tiverton’s 18.2, Jamestown’s 19.3, and Smithfield’s 19.5.
It takes a cynic, indeed, to tell the people of Rhode Island that these are encouraging results. At least Education Commissioner Deborah Gist expressed “concerns about the one-year decline in percent proficient in our middle schools,” although one wonders why longer-term drops and stagnation at the elementary and high school levels aren’t matters of concern, as well.